Zarin & Steinmetz Secures Dismissal of Article 78 Challenge to Continental Commons Project and Defeats Motion for Reargument
Lee Lefkowitz and Vincent Pedone secured a significant litigation victory on behalf of the developers of Continental Commons, a proposed commercial development at the intersection of U.S. Route 9 and Snook Road in the Town of Fishkill. In two successive decisions, the Dutchess County Supreme Court first dismissed an Article 78 proceeding challenging the project and subsequently denied the petitioners’ attempt to reargue that dismissal.
The proceeding, Friends of Fishkill Supply Depot, et al. v. Town of Fishkill Planning Board, et al., challenged the Town Planning Board Chair’s April 16, 2025 signing of the final site plan for Continental Commons–which approval Z&S also secured on behalf of the client.
In its Decision and Order, the Court agreed that the challenge was untimely, and rejected the petitioners’ arguments for application of the longer four-month Article 78 limitations period and for equitable estoppel. The Court granted Z&S’s motion to dismiss, denied the petitioners’ request for a preliminary injunction as academic, dismissed the petition, and then denied reargument.
Together, the decisions preserve the dismissal of the challenge to Continental Commons and represent another successful defense by Zarin & Steinmetz of a significant land-use approval it obtained.