Zarin & Steinmetz Secures Complete Dismissal of Orange County Supreme Court Case Challenging Sewer Infrastructure Improvements for Housing Development
Lee Lefkowitz and Aaron Warner secured a conclusive victory on behalf of its client, the developer of the Forest Chateaus residential project in the Town of Monroe. In a Decision and Order dated October 14, 2026, the Orange County Supreme Court granted Z&S’s summary judgment motion dismissing all claims brought against the project and its developers.
The lawsuit, brought by a neighbor to the project, challenged the construction of a sewer line extension serving the Forest Chateaus development. The plaintiff alleged that the developers had trespassed on its neighboring property and undertaken construction activities without the necessary authority or approvals.
The Court agreed with Z&S’s arguments and rejected those claims in their entirety, finding that the sewer improvements were constructed pursuant to a long-standing utility easement and with the requisite municipal authorizations.
The decision marks the conclusion of a dispute that sought to halt infrastructure improvements required to serve the new 185-unit residential development, and could have held up the project. The ruling confirms the legal authority to undertake the approved sewer improvements and allows the project to move to completion.
The case is Garden Housing, Inc. v. Forest Chateus, et al., EF010937/2024.